Postpartum tears: experiences with clients who carry birth trauma

tisk_Terezka_37We didn't meet by chance. We're joined by a passion for helping women, mothers, and their children live a life that brings them joy. Each of us comes at it from a different side, but we found that one theme connects us. Birth. With me it's obvious… and with Lenka from the project Prosím Spinkej the connection only shows up on a second look. Some of the trouble with children's sleep points back to a traumatic birth.

You can read her article on the topic, including practical tips for easing the troubles, HERE.

Lenka asked me whether I'd answer a few questions she keeps running into at her talks. And she wanted it to offer some solution her clients can use to bring themselves relief. I was very glad to say yes.

I'm not a psychologist, so take what follows as my own plain, "unschooled" experience with dozens of women who came to me asking for help, and who left with a calm heart and, I think I can say, a relieved smile.

How often do you encounter birth trauma in your practice, and what feelings most often accompany it?

I meet women who have been through birth trauma very often. It's almost half of my clients. At first I thought it was a fairly rare topic, but over time I came to understand that here, sadly, it's very common.

The feelings that recur in these women are: a feeling of a stolen birth, the experience of being violated, helplessness, anger at the system and then at oneself for not being able to avert it. Then women also often mention the guilt they feel toward their child.

In fact, we always find some form of guilt there, and I hold that this is one of the most destructive feelings that appears in connection with birth trauma. It directly affects the fragile bond between a mother and her newborn.

makroGerberaDo mothers with birth trauma come to you who are, on top of that, troubled by the same problems with their baby? Or rather, from the stories you know, what all can this hardship affect?

Women and women's stories vary enormously. So does how much they see of the connections. But if I had to pick out the common traits I notice in these mothers, it would most often be an anxious relationship with the child.

We often trace it back to the woman admitting to herself that she's making something up to her child, because in her own eyes she failed at the start of their life. So she subconsciously reads every cry as proof that she's a bad mother and is failing all over again. She then tries with all her strength to make up for this imperfection of hers. She does whatever she reads in their eyes, even past her own limits. In effect she sacrifices herself for them, and that sacrifice can never heal the original wound the birth caused.

The woman feels herself that going against herself and "serving" the child without limits isn't good, but she can't do otherwise. As I said, when the child shows displeasure, she takes it as proof of her own imperfection as a mother. So she tries to remove the points of friction in everyday life, even at the cost of blurring her own boundaries.

Let's be honest: this suppressed self of hers and this disregard for her own needs can lead to her blowing up. She boils over, she's unpleasant, she's mean, she shouts… which pours a few more drops of oil into the cauldron of guilt. And the whole destructive spiral starts turning again.

And the child? They're confused, and through their demands they try to get the mother to show them how far they can go and what's already over the line. So they're searching and groping their way too.

Then there's a second stance I see. The guilt is so corrosive that the woman can't stand the daily reminder of her fateful failure, which is her own child. She may see them as a witness to her lapse, so she detaches emotionally to make it hurt less.

She longs deeply for a loving relationship with her child, and at the same time she feels a barrier between them that won't let her show what she feels truthfully and in full.

kapkaNAkytceMakroThis inner conflict then leads once again to a strengthening of the guilt and to a further withdrawal from feeling.

As for the little ones, I can't say I've seen patterns of behavior I could generalize from. I don't see them in person and I only have what their mothers tell me about them.

Perhaps I could name at least two characteristics that recur: the child is touch-shy, unable to bear physical closeness, or the child can't be soothed and cries for a long time with no obvious cause. Both of these ease off fairly quickly once the woman works through her trauma and starts to approach the child in a relaxed way, which means without guilt.

What do you consider a traumatic birth? Can it be described as a style of birth, or does a lot also depend on how we approach what we go through?

From my perspective, it actually doesn't matter what happened during the birth. I focus on the feelings the woman went through. No two birth trauma stories are alike. One mother has trauma from a birth that looked beautiful and natural, with no interventions, because she expected something different from herself or from the person with her. Another woman went through sheer hell. And both can be living with feelings that are equally hard.

It's a very individual thing, and expectations, unfulfilled longings and the woman's own makeup, her philosophy of life, all play a part.

If I had to pick out the realities that show up often on the road to birth trauma, it would be these:

  • Nothing about me without me: the staff don't tell the woman enough about what they're doing to her. She feels like a piece of meat. She sees herself as a nameless number that has to be processed. What's missing is empathy and humane, sensitive treatment.
  • Threats and instilling fear: it's not unusual for women to describe genuinely dreadful sentences they heard from the staff looking after them. They're often threats that put the words death and child in the same sentence. The woman feels backed into a corner with no way to act, and senses she has no say over her own birth. Sometimes humiliation from doctors and nurses comes with it. Mockery, inappropriate remarks and disrespectful behavior can do a great deal of harm.
  • Disrespect for a sacred process: this one is a little harder to grasp. Trauma can come out of a mismatch in basic attitudes to life. When a woman trusts her body and her child, and then finds herself in a maternity ward that relies almost entirely on machines, her intuition gets blunted. At the same time her ability to respond properly to the child's needs shuts down, and she feels she's losing contact with herself.She loses the connection to her own wisdom, and even to the baby, who she stops sensing under the pressure of charts, waivers and an environment often full of fear.The trauma then comes from knowing that she had what it took to give birth under her own power and in peace, and she wasn't allowed to, because she kept being pulled out of her focus.

Birth is a sensitive matter that, thankfully, is much talked about these days. Mental readiness certainly plays a big role. In a hospital birth, so does the approach there and the interventions. So where should we look for someone to blame, and is it even necessary to look for anyone?

That's a hard question for me to answer. At first glance it's tempting to pin birth trauma on the system, which sadly still doesn't take the sensitivity of the birthing process seriously enough, and doesn't give women an environment and services that would spare them the feeling of having to fight for a natural birth in the hospital.

This is probably something we need to go through, and it's needed so that society can learn its lesson and perhaps, hopefully, then adjust the practices that are counterproductive and take away (healthy) women's competence to give birth to their child naturally and without interventions.

I go further with my clients. I'm of the view that every experience we've been through holds some gift for us in the form of a lesson.

In practice, what has worked for me is to work with a woman with birth trauma so that she names for herself what this intense, painful experience taught her about herself. What realization she can take from it. That leads her further, because once she's read the message, once she understands it, she can make her peace with it. And with that comes the knowledge that a future birth doesn't have to repeat the same lesson.

So my approach is non-blaming. We don't point fingers, but look for a way to grasp the experience differently. To look at it from another perspective, to realize what it was meant to bring, and then, finally, to let it go. Which goes hand in hand with forgiving oneself.

nebeI know it isn't for every woman. Some need to remain in the role of the victim, to live something through, to carry the weight of what happened to them. Even so, the women who come to me have all been ready, so far, to stop looking for someone to blame and to find inner peace. Maybe I could call it reconciliation, and that is an immense strength. It always moves me to see a woman feel the relief and soften all over when she puts her trauma down and steps into peace.

How can we command our mind to calm down and stop tormenting us? Is there some at-home guide for how to come to terms with it in our thoughts and feelings? 

It would be lovely if I could wave a magic wand and hand women a simple procedure for working through birth trauma in the safety of their own home. I'm afraid I have nothing like that up my sleeve, but I'll give you at least three tips for working on painful feelings in everyday life, so their edges wear down and, with time and regular practice, they gradually fall away.

  • A very powerful practice is repeatedly making contact with the Spiritual Heart. It's a place we always have within reach, we just often don't know it's there. When we reach it, we rise above judging ourselves, and we get to fully feel that we are enough.

That sense of being enough does women with birth trauma a great deal of good. In fact it does us all good, whatever we happen to be going through. It's a kind of coming home, into a harbor of unconditional love and safety.

Because this is hard to explain in theory but fairly easy to do in practice, I've recorded a guided meditation for this purpose that will take you into the Spiritual Heart. You can download it for free HERE.

  • When painful memories and the feelings tied to them come, it's good to become aware of which part of the body these feelings gather in. Then I recommend giving them a color and a shape. Telling yourself, for instance, that the guilt over a botched birth is like a gray cloud sitting on your chest.

And once I have this feeling made concrete, I can work with it in a playful way, in the style of Mental harmonization, or, if it suited you, the feeling can be sent away with the help of the inflatable balloon technique.

I know this isn't an easy path. You need to hold on to your alertness, and when a negative feeling comes, not to pick at it the way we're used to, but to notice it gently, visualize it, and then work it through.

That brings a very important side effect with it. When we name a feeling this concretely and visualize it, we're accepting it. If it were suppressed, we couldn't get to it or work with it. Acceptance is the foundation of being able to forgive (yourself). Even if that acceptance were five percent, it's a big step forward.

krokusIf the feeling won't come out of your body, know that you aren't ready yet to work the trauma through and let it go. Which doesn't mean tomorrow can't be different. It takes trying, and not letting the first attempts put you off. Over time, both the ability to transform feelings and the speed of it get better.

  • At this point, the same beginning applies as in the last one. So we become aware of the place where the trauma sits, and then observe it for a while with our inner sight. We don't visualize the birth experience, only the feelings that bother us and are tied to it. We don't judge them, don't analyze them, we observe. After a little while we start breathing into that place. The breath is natural and relaxed, and we watch the place let go. If it suits you, you can also use the colored breath technique, which you can easily learn from the guided meditation in the eBook Colorful Breath for a Smooth Birth. I deliberately recorded the meditation so that it can be used by non-pregnant people, men, and even children too.

My wish for every woman and her child is that they give birth, and are born , in a dignified and safe environment that supports contact between the mother and her baby. And for the women who can't tear themselves away from their birth story because of the tears, I wish the courage to put that weight down.

You don't have to carry birth pain inside you. It can be turned into something useful. I know that, and once you really, truly set about your birth trauma, you'll agree with me.

Also read the article "Birth trauma can disrupt sleep" by Lenka from the project Prosím Spinkej.

Tereza Kramer
I was given a gift: insight into the human mind, and into the light in a child's soul. I teach people to work with their mind so it serves them, not the other way around. I help pregnant women find trust in themselves, in their body, in their baby, in their own quiet voice. And I help parents understand their children, so life together gets easier. This work is my calling, and I love it. Read my story. I love passing on what I've learned, and I keep writing about it. You'll find more on my blog.